Voice of the Child Reports:
When Does Their Opinion Matter?
There is no "Magic Age" in Ontario. Learn how Courts weigh a child's "Views and Preferences" and why a Voice of the Child Report (VOC) might be your best evidence.
Legal Review: This guide was reviewed by Deepa Tailor, Senior Family Lawyer, to ensure compliance with the Children's Law Reform Act (Section 64) regarding a child's right to be heard (2026).
Too Busy to Read? The 30-Second Answer
The "Magic Age":
There is no specific age (like 12 or 14) where a child gets to decide custody in Ontario. The decision always rests with the Judge until age 18.
The Weight:
However, the older the child, the more weight the court gives their view.
- •Under 10: Views are heard but heavily scrutinized for coaching.
- •12-14: Views are strongly considered.
- •16+: It is nearly impossible to force a 16-year-old to visit a parent they refuse to see.
The Tool:
A Voice of the Child (VOC) Report is a private report where a professional interviews the child to record their views without forcing them to testify in court.
How Much Does Age Matter?
Judicial discretion shifts as the child matures.
The Young Child (Under 10)
Low
Courts assume young children are easily manipulated ("Coached"). Their stated preference is often viewed as a reflection of the custodial parent's wish.
The Pre-Teen (11-14)
Medium-High
The court looks for "independence of thought." Can they articulate *why* they want to change the schedule? (e.g., "Dad lives closer to my soccer practice" vs. "Mom lets me play video games").
The Teenager (15-17)
Very High
While the Judge *can* order a 16-year-old to visit a parent, enforcing it is practically impossible. Courts rarely make orders that teenagers will simply vote with their feet and ignore.
Private Report (VOC) vs. Public Investigator (OCL)
Voice of the Child (VOC) Report
Fast (2-4 weeks).
Paid privately ($1,500 - $3,000+).
"Non-Evaluative." The interviewer simply records what the child said. They do not investigate deep parenting issues or make recommendations on what is "best."
Office of the Children's Lawyer (OCL)
Slow (6-12 months).
Free (Government funded).
"Evaluative." The clinician investigates the whole family and tells the Judge what to do (recommends custody).
What Will They Ask My Child?
Parents often panic about the interview. It is not an interrogation. Professionals use open-ended questions:
The "Three Wishes" Question
"If you could change three things about your life, what would they be?"
The Schedule
"How does the current schedule work for your school/sports?"
The Feelings
"How do you feel when you are at Mom's house? How about Dad's?"
NOT The "Choice"
They rarely ask "Who do you want to live with?" directly, as it puts too much pressure on the child.
Common Myths About Preferences
The Myth
"The Age of 12"
Myth: "When my son turns 12, he can choose to live with me."
The Reality
"The Best Interests Test"
Reality: Age 12 is an urban legend. It is just a guideline for maturity. If a 12-year-old wants to live with a parent who is abusive or neglectful, the court will overrule the child's wish.
Common Questions About VOC Reports
Listen to Your Child.
If your child is asking for a change in the schedule, ignoring them can lead to resentment. We help you arrange Voice of the Child Reports to ensure their wishes are heard legally.
Book Your Custody Strategy Session
Deepa Tailor, Senior Family Lawyer
Deepa Tailor is the founder of Tailor Law. She regularly works with VOC professionals to elevate the voices of children in high-conflict separation matters.
View Full Bio